Christmas with Holly

6.3 (100 votes)• 2012• 90m•Released

Storyline & Plot Summary

After being dumped at the altar on her wedding day, Maggie Conway moves to the island town of Friday Harbor in Washington State, where she meets Mark Nagle, the local coffee shop owner.

Production Details

Languages: English

Director: Allan Arkush

Starring Cast: Sean Faris, Eloise Mumford, Lucy Gallina, Dana Watkins, Daniel Eric Gold, Vanessa Matsui

Cast

Sean Faris

Mark Nagle

Eloise Mumford

Maggie Conway

Lucy Gallina

Holly Nagle

Dana Watkins

Scott Nagle

Daniel Eric Gold

Alex Nagle

Vanessa Matsui

Cara

Fiona Forsythe

Chloe

Catherine Bérubé

Kate Conway

Cynthia Galant

Megan

Gary Levert

Don

Rhonda McLean

Principal Stewart

Alex Paxton-Beesley

Shelby

Wade Carroll

Running Man

Andy Smith

Father of the Bride

Jean Yoon

Ms. Dylan

Darcy Donavan

Shelby's Friend (uncredited)

Audience Reviews & Detailed Breakdown

Read and share community scores for Christmas with Holly

2 Reviews

CinematicExpert

2 days ago

9.5 / 10

Story: 10•Cast: 9.5•OST: 9•Rewatch: 9

An absolute masterpiece of modern cinema! The character arcs are deeply emotional and the musical score heightens every single scene.

DramaEnthusiast

1 week ago

8.8 / 10

Story: 9•Cast: 9•OST: 8.5•Rewatch: 8.5

Great pacing throughout the entire story. The leads have insane chemistry together. Highly recommended for anyone looking for a compelling watch.

Recommended Reviews

Similar titles recommended for fans of Christmas with Holly

Red Lodge

Movie - 2013, 2h 15m

4.8 / 10

RomanceComedyDrama

A man proposes to his boyfriend. The offer of marriage is accepted, and then quickly rejected -- all in the days leading up to Christmas.

View Details

All the Best

Movie - 2016, 2h 15m

2.6 / 10

ComedyDramaRomance

A disillusioned opera star, a lonely pastry chef, and a divorced Don Juan with an amorous history offstage make for choice ingredients in this poignant romantic tale spiced with Christmas cookies, borscht, and an alarming quantity of deadly insecticide. Director Tribuson demonstrates a deft talent for juggling comic romantic disasters from a woman’s point of view as her characters negotiate the bamboozling ways of love. Middle-aged Verica (acclaimed actress Marinković) pours her heart into her café’s pastries, but she can’t seem to find a like-minded lover until a duplicitous handyman with pheromones to spare and an eye for the ladies sets off a chain of unforeseen adventures all tied together by one fateful plate of tasty treats.

View Details

The Secret Santa Project

Movie - 2025, 2h 15m

8.0 / 10

ComedyDrama

Landing her first 'adult' job in the council's accounts department, new graduate Jolene is excited for the annual Secret Santa. But instead of exchanging typical gifts, she proposes a bold twist: perform a meaningful good deed for your assigned colleague and share the anonymous story.

View Details

Christmas in Boston

Movie - 2005, 2h 15m

5.6 / 10

TV MovieComedyDrama

Gina and Seth have been pen pals for 13 years and now will have the chance to meet. Both used their best friends pictures to send to each other and now will let their friends meet. True love is found in the end for all.

View Details

The Perfect Christmas

Movie - 2023, 2h 15m

2.0 / 10

FamilyComedy

On Christmas Eve, the Perfect family experience a series of outrageous misadventures, pranks and criminal activity that may jeopardize their chance at The Perfect Christmas.

View Details

A Holiday I Do

Movie - 2023, 2h 15m

3.5 / 10

RomanceComedyDrama

When a small town single mom falls for her ex-husband's beautiful and sophisticated wedding planner, she'll need some Christmas magic to fix the chaos that ensues.

View Details